Scott Hanselman

Review: Pleo gets sent back to the Dinosaur Pound

January 29, '08 Comments [25] Posted in Reviews
Sponsored By

imageUPDATE: In record time, Sarah from Ugobe included feedback in the comments below. Just be clear, I was reticent to do a review at all, because I know how much work goes into things like this, especially for a small startup that pours their hearts into a product like this. It just turns out that it wasn't for me, and I had high, perhaps unreasonable expectations that weren't met. That said, please do read Sarah from Ugobe's thoughts in the comments below.

I've always wanted a little robot, maybe a dog or something that would wander around the house and be charming, but wouldn't require, ahem, care and feeding. I have enough trouble keeping myself and my family fed, the last thing I need is an actual animal to keep alive. I'm not a dog or cat person, sue me. ;)

Anyway, the Sony Aibo was a good idea, but it was (and is) too expensive (unless you, Dear Reader, want to loan/sell me your Aibo?) for my tastes.

This Christmas I got myself the family a Pleo baby dinosaur using blog money, although the WAF on this one was at a new low. Seriously. But, I persevered.

Again, as with the iPhone, the Wife was correct.

image

What a profoundly disappointing toy. To be clear, it is a toy and an expensive one at that. Fortunately The Sharper Image has a good return policy.

The Bad

  • It's slow. It doesn't wander around the house. If you leave it alone for more than 10 minutes it "falls asleep." Basically you need to actively touch it for it to stay awake.
  • Horrendous battery life. It has a pack of what looks like 4 AA batteries lashed together that fits inside it's stomach. However, you get only one pack, you have to remove it to charge and you're lucky to get an hour out of it. Any idea that this thing would wander around the house for a half-day are dashed at this point.
  • It's noisy. I don't mean it's noisy with cute dinosaur noises, I mean it's noisy with gear gnashing sounds. This destroys any sense of realism, for me. The wife commented also.
  • It's less-than-clever and slow in the head. You have to poke at it for 10-15 seconds, it seems, before it reacts with tricks and such
  • Within a few minutes (maybe 10) of petting it, the paint started to flake off. The website says this "makes your Pleo personal" but I think it just shows that painted rubber is a sub-optimal fake skin.
  • Still no word on when a Developer SDK is coming out. Perhaps expectations of a company are high given blogs and what not, but when a company has no visible blog and is slow with the updates (cough: Mozy) then folks quickly lose confidence, IMHO.

The Good

  • It's got an SD slot and tiny USB, so upgrades are supposed to be easy, unfortunately according to their site even now as we approach the February after Christmas there is still no upgrade to their OS. Why should I care? Because apparently the current Pleo LifeOS has a bug where the Pleo doesn't adapt or grow correctly.
  • It's fairly sturdy and nice to look at if it's not moving. So, as a piece of sculpture, sure. As soon as it moves, the illusion is over.

Perhaps I would have enjoyed it more if it were faster, quieter, more interesting, but even my 2 year old grew tired and frustrated with it as it didn't "engage" or seem to notice he was there as he tried to feed it the plastic leaf it comes with. As soon as it failed to connect with him, that was the end of Pleo. Maybe I'm being too harsh, but I had high hopes and was very bummed by this whole thing and won't make this mistake again.

If you can borrow or rent or observe one first, I'd really recommend caution with this robot.

About Scott

Scott Hanselman is a former professor, former Chief Architect in finance, now speaker, consultant, father, diabetic, and Microsoft employee. He is a failed stand-up comic, a cornrower, and a book author.

facebook twitter subscribe
About   Newsletter
Sponsored By
Hosting By
Dedicated Windows Server Hosting by ORCS Web
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 12:20:36 AM UTC
I wondered about those things.

Sounds like a Roomba is more fun<g>
Darin
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 12:24:34 AM UTC
Sounds like you got a $40 robotic dog experience for $300. You description of Pleo sounds exactly like Tekno (without the usb port and fake skin). My 3 year old daughter loves her $40 dog though. :)
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 12:34:08 AM UTC
Maybe it's time Pleo got modded. Details at Pleo Dreams.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 12:36:16 AM UTC
Don't you hate it when the wife is right - again!
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 12:40:41 AM UTC
Hey Scott,

Sorry that Pleo wasn't your cup of tea. We definitely read reviews like yours and take them to heart and of course are content to take your return since it didn't work out!

We have tried hard to be clear on our website and in our communcations with registered customers and the press that Pleo's software is actively in development. We plan to release a minor upgrade in the *extremely* near future and a major one later this spring that will improve his performance, cease the "narcolepsy" and make his personality more adaptive and fun.

The PDK will be released in a few months. We expect a lot of fun work from third party developers. We have already seen the launch of two 3rd party modding envronments written by AIBO developers - MySkit Performance Editor for Pleo as well as YAPT. The robotics community has responded enthusiastically.

Again, though, Pleo isn't for everyone at this stage in the game. I'm glad you got to try him out and we really are listening - so feel free to share your thoughts in this space about features that you think folks would like to see.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 3:13:25 AM UTC
I really wanted a Pleo, but my owners have said no for now.
Looks like they may have been right.
That said, I have all kinds of fun adventures without them.

The Adventures of Schnubbs
http://www.schnubbs.com/blog/
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 3:16:46 AM UTC
sarah, you mention the PDK...this sounds interesting -- are there details around the PDK and what it will enable. will any of the microsoft robotics tools be helpful in writing applications using the PDK?
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 4:43:57 AM UTC
Please allow me to be the first to ask: "But can it run Linux?"
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 5:10:45 AM UTC
Will the WAF for HD-DVD be so high once Blu-ray becomes dominant? :P
glx
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 7:13:00 AM UTC

I am not surprised the batteries life suck because of all the motors and sensors in this thing. I thought the WTF would be higher for this one because it could have been a nice toy for the kid too.

I hope Ugobe works the kinks out... and try to lower the price.
Abdu
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 7:52:44 AM UTC
The PDK will come later this spring. Your question about MS robotics tools is a good one and I just don't know - I will forward that along to the engineering head on the PDK project and get back to you in this space.

There's a fair bit of discussion about it in our Forums if you're interested in following it there, and I can tell you that we're about to launch an introduction to what's forthcoming in the toolkit on a new "Developers" page on the website. There are some sample scripts (Python, Pawn) and information about Pleo's sound and motor systems, and a diagram of the Life OS architecture for your degustation. Should go up within the week if the elves can kick it out...
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 8:24:07 AM UTC
Sarah, thanks for your thoughtful responses.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 2:27:21 PM UTC
Hey Now Scott,
That WAF Chart cracks me up everytime i see it.
Hanselminutes fan,
Catto
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 3:26:06 PM UTC
I had high hopes and was very bummed by this whole thing and won't make this mistake again.
As a gadgeteer, you should take pride in the fact that you most likely will make this mistake again!
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 3:54:38 PM UTC
This sounds EXACTLY like the experience we had with the "WowWee Roboreptile Robotic Reptile." Talk about a waste of $100.
GlenH
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 4:04:14 PM UTC
"Sarah, thanks for your thoughtful responses."

WHAT IS THIS?! After reading Rob's recent blog post I assumed that this Scott Hanselman was an incredible BAD ASS who wouldn't take any heat from the "Red Shirts", and yet after *obviously* exposing a sub-par product with numerous issues, he turns all nice under the lights of public scrutiny?! I expected a nastier, angrier, dick of a Hanselman...I wanted to blog about how awesome Scott was as he RAPID FIRED OFF his rebuttal to the Dino-PR person and after she replied with a "Yeah, gee, I never thought about it that way" would finish with a "That's Toy-User-Acceptance-Testing-Baby!"...but I see that's not to be. FOR SHAME Scott...for shame. Justice was so wrong about you...my faith is shattered.

D
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 4:59:11 PM UTC
D'Arcy - LOL.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 5:13:39 PM UTC
I had an aibo for about a month - also from Sharper Image. I couldn't justify the $1800 plus it didn't work well on carpet or in dim light (which was most of my house). But nothing compares to the aibo. Since then, I've pretty much given up until they start making something more like the aibo.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 5:25:04 PM UTC
It's a little off topic, but how did you generate the WAF chart?
Sean S.
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 6:25:53 PM UTC
Oh man, how did you generate the WAF chart indeed.

If it's not already started, I'm thinking the Silverlight WAF chart generator!

Maybe even get a little kick back and sell the concept to xceed ;-)
Matt
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 6:38:51 PM UTC
Seems like your review is no different from Pogue's
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 7:18:22 PM UTC
borrow or rent or observe one first


I'll be sure to do that next time I am at my local robot dinosaur lender/renter/zoo. :-)
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 11:06:48 PM UTC
Forget the dino - you need to get yourself a TARDIS :) Even if you don't want the sounds and lights it makes a great ornament...

http://www.amazon.com/Doctor-Who-Electronic-Control-Playset/dp/B0012DTWGW
Thursday, January 31, 2008 3:36:34 AM UTC
I'm with your wife on this one, Scott. An Aibo? A Pleo? Robots = impersonal, not cuddly, no personality. Incidentally, these are among some of the reasons why I refuse to let Justice convince me that we should have robot Astro-children instead of real ones. ;)
Thursday, March 20, 2008 2:08:17 AM UTC
my pleo is constantly asleep? i have tried everything to wake him up, he just snores, any tips?
shaz
Comments are closed.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in any way.