Scott Hanselman

Set Tops Are Back - Microsoft Media Room

June 29, 2007 Comment on this post [7] Posted in Musings
Sponsored By


I know little about IPTV other than I figure it's Television over the Internet. Heh.

Announced earlier this month was Microsoft Media Room, an update to Microsoft's IPTV platform. Long Zheng (fantastic blog) had the scoop four weeks ago when he noticed Microsoft trademarking it in Australia.

I'd personally really like to see Microsoft get this right. Remember UltimateTV? Microsoft's also been talking to Comcast (my provider) about Microsoft's Foundation software for a while.

There's rumor around that say that Microsoft's Foundation software will run on the craptaculous Comcast Motorola 3412 DVR. There's also word that Tivo's software can run on that Motorola 3412 as well. Either why, I needs me an upgrade.


You can find a gallery of images of the Xbox 360 IPTV interface over at Engadget. It'd be interesting if someone put together a matrix of all the IPTV options out there so we could get an idea of what our choices are going to be in the future. There's already a lot of XBoxes out there, and I'm unclear as to what software will be running on what box. 

For example, I have a Motorola DVR from Comcast, and an Xbox 360. I don't think this is an unusual scenario. I have Verizon FIOS for my Internet. IPTV comes out, now what? Do I run it on my Comcast DVR? Maybe not, perhaps I cancel with Comcast, and Verizon sends me a new set top box. Or, do I use the Xbox 360? If I want IPTV in another room do I go buy another Xbox?


I'd love for the XBox360 to take on this role. If you've never seen the Media blade with in the 360 or watched a download HD movie on it, you're missing quite a treat. The experience is butter. Truly. Even better is the Media Center integration on the Xbox.

The problem with all this isn't a problem my Mom will have. She'll get one box from her television provider and it'll work. No Problem.

It's me (I?) who will have problems. I just want to watch TV. How will I choose?

Hardware Software Transport Notes
Motorola 3412 Poo Coax Cable It current sucks so bad that it's personally embarrassing for me, and I had nothing to do with it's development. But, the hardware is out there. Whose software will unleash it?
Xbox 360 Microsoft IP Has fantastic potential and I already have the box. Who will offer the service though?
Microsoft Media Center Microsoft Coax or possibly IP Media Center could potentially support IP TV. For Coax or over-the-air-HD it's great, but they are expensive and the hardware is often loud.
XBox 360 to a Media Center Microsoft RDP I can remote into a Media Center from my Xbox.
Tivo Tivo Coax (so far) Everyone loves their Tivo, and they "nearly had IPTV" two years ago. Still, their software could run on Motorola's hardware and be distributed through cable.
AppleTV Apple IP (via iTunes) Video quality was initially quite poor, but more and more offerings are available at at least SDTV resolutions. This will no doubt get better.
Front Row Apple IP Apple's Media Center software. Doesn't support "TV" only iTunes.
OpenSource OpenSource Coax/IP There's lots of great open source Media Center Software for folks with TV Cards
DemocracyTV Non-Profit IP Video Podcasting Client and much much more. Has some good HD content.

Either way, do head over to and and check it out. Click on Find Your Local Provider and you'll get a list of the providers that can offer Media Room today. Note AT&T U-verse is listed for the US. I've never heard of this service, and their ordering site is down, so I can't see if it's available in my area.


International (non-US) Readers, what's the word about IPTV and set-top boxes where YOU are?

About Scott

Scott Hanselman is a former professor, former Chief Architect in finance, now speaker, consultant, father, diabetic, and Microsoft employee. He is a failed stand-up comic, a cornrower, and a book author.

facebook twitter subscribe
About   Newsletter
Hosting By
Hosted in an Azure App Service
June 29, 2007 22:38
Have you seen TVTonic? ( It has a nice MCML interface for Media Center that runs great on the 360 (much slicker than the RDP + HTML / WPF interfaces). Could be better of course, but it's an impressive start :D

I'm holding out for IPTV through Media Center... Wishful thinking?
June 29, 2007 23:53
Until these devices have the versatility of XBMC I will pass on them. There is nothing more frustrating than fighting with the DRM that is shoved down your throat by these device vendors.
June 30, 2007 1:14
I freakin' want that!

It would be nice if Microsoft pulls this off and add another competitor to the market, like DirecTV did years ago. Or at least replace the crappy software currently on the ComCast DVR boxes with their mediaroom software. TimeWarner sold to ComCast in Florida a few months ago and so far the internet access has gone down three times in 20 days. And now they want to replace my perfectly good Moto DVR with some new version.

June 30, 2007 1:14
I just blogged about something similar. I'm looking to centralized all my media is one place. I didn't bother looking at IPTV mostly because I'm happy in my current provider.

Neuros also has some potential. However, everything seems to be in alpha version.
June 30, 2007 7:35
Microsoft definitely has plans for the Xbox360 to enter into this role:

I bet we'll hear more about it at E3 (and it's probably no surprise that we're hearing about MediaRoom now, with E3 around the corner).

As a happy Xbox360 owner and frustrated Comcast customer, I'm hoping Microsoft does this right.
June 30, 2007 7:45
I just switched to Vista Media Center + HDHomeRun + Xbox360 and I have to say I am impressed. I had been running Vista Media Center with an analog tuner and the comcast/motorola box but that was painful.
July 20, 2007 2:17
I am from Germany and I have a friend who is using the IPTV on a VDSL connection. The settopbox in use runs MS IPTV but not yet Mediaroom. it is expected "in the second half of the year" ... whatever that means ;)
anyway, except for the music streaming and picture viewer it is more or less the same thing.

I have seen it in action and there are many problems at the moment:

1. the content is streamed in h.264 which sounds good at first, but if you realize that the sources for those streams are usually DVB-S channels with low bandwidth, the result of a second compression is total garbage.

2. HDTV streams have acceptable quality... using about 12mbit bandwith, but it takes anywhere from 1 to 30s to switch to a protected (encrypted) hdtv channel... thats not what I call ultra-fast channel switching :(

3. due to the multicast there are problems if multiple boxes are connected at one household. the effect can be that all boxes are activated at the same time if one of them is programmed to record a show.

Comments are closed.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my employer's view in any way.